Practical commentary for founders, operators and private members' clubs. Written to be useful rather than promotional, and kept short enough to read before a meeting.
What the agreement does that the articles cannot, and the five numbers the negotiation is really about: consent list, drag threshold, leaver terms, warranty cap, board seats.
AI drafts read well, which is the problem. The clauses that go wrong are the ones that look fine: governing law, who owns what, how it ends and what happens when it does.
The label on the contract does not decide the person's status; how the work actually runs does. How the three categories differ, what each contract must contain, and where founders get caught.
Equity, vesting, leavers, decisions, IP and the way out. The conversation is awkward because everyone is still friends, which is the best time to have it.
They look alike and HMRC treats them very differently. Why SEIS and EIS investors need an ASA, when a loan note is right, and the terms that matter in both.
Two clubs on the same street can hold entirely different licences. The distinction turns on how the club is owned and how its members join, not on how it looks from the pavement.
Service charge at a members' club is no longer a matter of house policy. The Employment (Allocation of Tips) Act 2023 makes fair allocation a legal duty, with a written policy and a three-year record.
Membership generates unusually rich personal data, and the rules that bite hardest are not in the UK GDPR at all. PECR governs the marketing email, and it works differently.
Private clubs are not outside discrimination law. The associations provisions of the Equality Act 2010 govern admission, benefits and expulsion, with a narrow set of exceptions.
Members are consumers. That single fact brings the Consumer Rights Act 2015, the cancellation regulations and the new subscription rules to bear on your joining form.
The choice between an unincorporated members' club, a company limited by guarantee and a proprietary operating company decides who is personally on the hook when something goes wrong.